Wine Pop Tab Purse progress part 2

I have almost finished all the pieces and getting ready for assembly.  I also went last night to go get the material for the liner.  I loved the material I found it matches the thread perfectly.  I am having troubles deciding on what color plastic canvas to use.  I got some red but I think its to bright as it does not match the thread.  I have some leftover black from the last purse.

RED

BLACK